Saint Francis’ “Disastrous” Meeting With Pope Innocent III: 1210 A D

March 14, 2013 — 5 Comments
From the movie, Brother Sun Sister Moon, 1972, Faulkner Graham and Alec Guinness

From the movie, Brother Sun Sister Moon, 1972, Faulkner Graham and Alec Guinness

Saint Francis  (as we now know him)  was summoned to  Rome to meet Pope Innocent III in 1210 A D.

Poor Francesco of Assisi (Saint Francis)   had been a very bad boy.  In fact, he was so bad that the Catholic elite  in the little town of Assisi had burned down Francesco’s  church.

Why? Francesco was living as Jesus had lived: with a tender heart that loved all. As Jesus had instructed, Francesco looked after the poor and the widows and orphans.

Francesco  had taken a vow of poverty. His fellow brothers in Christ (later the Franciscan Order) were so poor, in fact,  that they defiantly did not wear shoes.

Then why did the Catholic elite burn down his church outside of Assisi?

Well, Francesco’s church was rather “artistic” — sheep and lambs came  to mass with their shepherds. Field flowers graced their modest altar — not the groomed flowers of the rich and traditional church.

But it was not solely about fashion, it never is.

It was about money.

Elite Catholicism  saw Francesco as a threat to the infrastructure  — for he was not about power, he was about responsibility. The people of Assisi had left the traditional church to follow the pure out-of-towner. The elite was losing their coin.

The meeting in Rome with Pope Innocent III was a disaster for the Catholic church.

What should have been a public chastisement of Francesco by the  Pope  was instead a public humiliation of the Pope Innocent III.

So overwhelmed by Francesco’s  love for God and for God’s people, so moved by his humility and charity,  the Pope abandoned his golden throne, stepped down to the “audience hall”, fell to his knees, and in an act  of complete humility, kissed the feet of barefooted  Francesco.

What’s in a name? The name “Pope Francis” carries irony and historical power. By taking the name “Francis”, it signifies something grand — the possibility of the triumph by a humble heart.

Below is the scene from the  1972 biography of Francesco of Assisi, Brother Sun, Sister Moon, directed by Franco Zeffirelli. Pope Leo III is brilliantly and hamily played by Alec Guinness; Francesco is played by Graham Faulkner.

It is long (16 minutes) and it is just one scene — but it is also brilliant in its subtlety. You might want to bookmark it and watch it at another time.

I can  not recall a stronger enactment of the Holy Spirit in the history of cinema  than this scene. Alec Guinness converted to Catholicism in 1954, long before this movie. But In his eyes and in his shaky hand pointing to the sky, you actually can see his dramatizing  the unseen work of the Holy Spirit.

For all of us who might believe that the infrastructure of the Catholic church is beyond repair; perhaps we should allow the glory of God through the Holy Spirit to work. For nothing is impossible for God: a pope came down from his throne and kissed the feet of a poor man and  now another Pope has  taken his name.

Loading Facebook Comments ...

5 responses to Saint Francis’ “Disastrous” Meeting With Pope Innocent III: 1210 A D

  1. Thanx for pointing out this out, David. I had completely missed the significance of the chosen name. Here’s hoping (and praying) that *all* followers of Christ, Catholic and protestant, follow the humble example of St. Francis as he followed his Lord.

    • Rick – Thanks, as always! I pray as well that the new Pope gets rid of the corrupt Roman Curia and brings the Word back into the church…. Best to you and appreciate your encouragement! David

  2. Beautiful clip, Mr. Kirkpatrick. Especially on this day. Thank you for sharing it with us. Oh that Zeffirelli. Knowing how to use all that beautiful pomp and glory and excess to his advantage….. just to make a simple point.

    • Thanks, Martin….I appreciate the comments. Zeffirelli is still going strong at 90….and recently has been advising the Papacity on image, according to reports! David

  3. is updated frequently with free advice about Google
    Ad – Words strategy, tactics, tips tricks and techniques for success
    in Ad – Words advertising. It has the highest ROI (Return of Invesment) in all advertisement channels.
    * Page SEO: Your page is optimized by various means which include,
    choosing the right keywords, placing them
    right, adding anchor text linking, adding call to action in various places on the page.

Leave a Reply

Text formatting is available via select HTML. <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>